For those of us with too many favorites for the top 5 list....

(Note: this is not in order. At all. Except for the top few)

1. Ami Mizuno (Sailor Moon)
2. Sayaka Miki (PMMM)
3. Fuu Hououji (Magic Knight Rayearth)
4. Makoto Kino (Sailor Moon)
5. Yuri Tsukikage (Heartcatch Precure)
6. Mitsuki Koyama (Full Moon o Sagashite)
7. Hikaru Shidou (Magic Knight Rayearth)
8. Usagi Tsukino (Sailor Moon)
9. Haruka Tenou (Sailor Moon)
10. Maron Kusakabe (Kamikaze Kaitou Jeanne)
11. Madoka Kaname (PMMM)
12. Michiru Kaiou (Sailor Moon)
13. Nozomi Yumehara (Yes! Precure 5)
14. Sakura Kinomoto (CCS)
15. Mami Tomoe (PMMM)
16. Utena Tenjou (RGU)
17. Itsuki Myoudouin (Heartcatch Precure)
18. Chibiusa Tsukino (Sailor Moon)
19. Minako Aino (Sailor Moon)
20. Rina Touin (Mermaid Melody)
21. Tsubomi Hanasaki (Heartcatch Precure)
22. Umika Misaki (PMKM)
23. Umi Ryuuzaki (Magic Knight Rayearth)
24. Kazumi Subaru (PMKM)
25. Komachi Akimoto (Yes! Precure 5) 

... that was tiring.

Honorary Mentions: Nico Kanna (PMKM), Miki Aono (Fresh Precure), Lucia Nanami (Mermaid Melody), Ako Shirabe (Suite Precure), and Madoka Aguri (Dokidoki Precure)

-_- 

I love a lot of magical girls, okay?

I did this one after seeing a disgraceful top 25 Magical Girl list on Sankaku Complex, but at the time I hadn't seen nearly as many shows as I have now, and kept changing my list. Needless to say I would be doing that a lot here too.

Creamy Mami/Yuu Morisawa
Sailor Jupiter/Makoto Kino
Princess Tutu/Ahiru
Sae Sawanoguchi (Magic User's Club)
Cure Marine/Erika Kurumi (Heartcatch Precure)
Utena Tenjou (Revolutionary Girl Utena)
Sailor Moon/Usagi Tsukino
Fashion Lala/Miho
Fancy Lala/Miho Shinohara
Ojamajo Doremi Harukaze
Atsuko "Akko" Kagami (Himitsu no Akko-chan - all versions)
Ojamajo Momoko Asuka
Magical Fairy Pelsia Hayami
Mami Tomoe (PMMM)
Pastel Yumi Hanazono
Minky Momo (1982 ver.)
Cure Blossom/Tsubomi Hanasaki
Cure White/Honoka Yukishiro
Saint Tail/Meimi Haneoka 
Hana no Ko LunLun
Mahou no Mako-chan
Madoka Kaname (PMMM)
Magical Emi/Mai Kazuki
Punie-chan (Dai Mahou Touge)
Comet-san

Okay... let's see if I can do this.

1. Sakura Kinomoto / Cardcaptor Sakura
2. Gretel / Otogi-jushi Akazukin
3. Yuri Tsukikage / Heartcatch Precure
3. Ako Shirabe / Suite Precure (Sorry, can't decide between these two
5. Akazukin / Otogi-jushi Akazukin
6. Pudding Fong / Tokyo Mew Mew
7. Doremi Harukaze / Ojamajo Doremi
8. Ahiru / Princess Tutu
9. Tsubomi Hanasaki / Heartcatch Precure
10. Rue / Princess Tutu
11. Persia Hayami / Mahou no Yousei Persia
12. Erika Kurumi / Heartcatch Precure
13. Miyuki Hoshizora / Smile Precure
14. Mint Aizawa / Tokyo Mew Mew
15. Love Momozono / Fresh Precure
16. Onpu Segawa / Ojamajo Doremi
17. Pop Harukaze / Ojamajo Doremi
18. Itsuki Myodouin / Heartcatch Precure
19. Setsuna Higashi / Fresh Precure
20. Sasami Kawai / Pretty Sammy
21. Princess Fine / Fushigiboshi no Futagohime
21. Kaori "Popuri" Nishino / Fushigi Mahou Fun Fun Pharmacy
22. Yuu Morisawa / Creamy Mami
23. Akane Hino / Smile Precure
24. Chibiusa /Sailor Moon
25. Sayaka Kurenai / Okusama wa Mahou Shoujo

Don't expect the order to be even 50% accurate. I looked through all the shows and characters I'm familiar with and was like "How strongly do I feel about this character?" And grouped them accordingly in rows of five.

My Top 25 Favorite Magical Girls are:

1. Rei Hino/Sailor Mars (Sailor Moon)

2. Yuri Tanima/Angel Lily (Wedding Peach)

3. Momoko Hanasaki/Wedding Peach/Angel Peach (Wedding Peach)

4. Hotaru Tomoe/Sailor Saturn (Sailor Moon)

5. Setsuna Meioh/Sailor Pluto (Sailor Moon)

6. Ami Mizuno/Sailor Mercury (Sailor Moon)

7. Sara (Mermaid Melody)

8. Zakuro Fujiwara/Mew Zakuro (Tokyo Mew Mew)

9. Ichigo Momomiya/Mew Ichigo (Tokyo Mew Mew)

10. Mint Aizawa/Mew Mint (Tokyo Mew Mew)

11. Takako (Pretear)

12. Nina Sakura (Ultra Maniac)

13. Himeno Awayuki (Pretear)

14. Rina Toin (Mermaid Melody)

15. Minako Aino/Sailor Venus (Sailor Moon)

16. Usagi Tsukino/Sailor Moon (Sailor Moon)

17. Lettuce Midorikawa/Mew Lettuce (Tokyo Mew Mew)

18. Makoto Kino/Sailor Jupiter (Sailor Moon) 

19. Luchia Nanami (Mermaid Melody)

20. Coco (Mermaid Melody)

21. Hinagiku Tamano/Angel Daisy (Wedding Peach)

22. Scarlet Ohara/Angel Salvia (Wedding Peach)

23. Noel (Mermaid Melody)

24. Hanon Hosho (Mermaid Melody)

25. Karen (Mermaid Melody)

Honorable Mentions:

. Miho Shinohara/Fancy Lala (Fancy Lala)

. Sakura Kinomoto (Cardcaptor Sakura)

. Chibiusa Tsukino/Sailor Chibi Moon (Sailor Moon)

. Pudding Fong/Mew Pudding (Tokyo Mew Mew)

. Seira (Mermaid Melody)

I know a lot of the Magical Girls I listed on here are all from some of the same series, but it's just I haven't watched or read a lot of Magical Girl series. So maybe when I watch or read more series then my list might change in the future.